The Penny Dreadful 500 (Season 37) (Penny Dreadful) Decks

MTGGoldfish is supported by its audience. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission.

The Penny Dreadful 500 (Season 37)

Format: Penny Dreadful
Date: 2025-06-14

Place	Deck	Pilot	Tabletop Price	MTGO Price	Toggle Deck
9 - 0	Simic Nadu	finaldefiance	$ 152	2 tix	Expand

7 - 2	Azorius Legends Aggro	mdog	$ 155	1 tix	Expand

6 - 2	Simic Nadu	bakert99	$ 144	2 tix	Expand

6 - 2	Simic Nadu	miniondevelopment	$ 143	2 tix	Expand

5 - 2	Simic Nadu	allanoncew	$ 145	2 tix	Expand

5 - 2	Boros Legends Aggro	binarysoloist	$ 77	1 tix	Expand

5 - 2	Necrotic Ooze Combo	egze249	$ 117	1 tix	Expand

4 - 2	Hardened Scales Affinity	brainlesss96	$ 127	1 tix	Expand

4 - 2	Oops All Lands	enakas	$ 150	2 tix	Expand

4 - 2	Simic Nadu	frzpop	$ 150	2 tix	Expand

4 - 2	Mono Blue Tempo	honorbound84	$ 61	1 tix	Expand

4 - 2	Excruciator Combo	mtgfan1996	$ 460	2 tix	Expand

4 - 2	Soulflayer	niched	$ 65	1 tix	Expand

4 - 2	Boros Legends Aggro	predrag133	$ 110	1 tix	Expand

4 - 2	Excruciator Combo	theshadowmaker	$ 460	2 tix	Expand

4 - 2	Unctus	tygrak	$ 158	2 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Red Deck Wins	violetteavi	$ 56	1 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Dimir Control	13eakers	$ 53	1 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Primal Prayers Combo	coupoutous	$ 47	2 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Excruciator Combo	dl23	$ 461	2 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Boros Legends Aggro	jhow1991	$ 91	1 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Stax	mapotofu	$ 198	2 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Mono White Angels	poposin_hyde	$ 120	2 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Boros Legends Aggro	rakura	$ 83	1 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Mono Black Midrange	sephy91	$ 238	2 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Excruciator Combo	swiftwarkite2	$ 460	2 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Hive Mind	waroomtguc	$ 508	2 tix	Expand

2 - 2	Excruciator Combo	shainas	$ 461	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Red Deck Wins	ffffffff	$ 56	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Lifegain Midrange	jaycearveduin	$ 174	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Laelia Cascade	tomsoniq	$ 41	3 tix	Expand

2 - 4	Boros Legends Aggro	ailith	$ 105	1 tix	Expand

2 - 4	Mono Black Vampires	gearhulkazul	$ 240	1 tix	Expand

1 - 2	Oops All Lands	8bitavenger	$ 133	2 tix	Expand

1 - 2	Boros Humans	miss_input	$ 88	1 tix	Expand

1 - 2	Bard Class	wizzerinus	$ 77	1 tix	Expand

1 - 3	Excruciator Combo	garcia_edu	$ 460	2 tix	Expand

1 - 3	Boros Legends Aggro	magnus24112	$ 81	1 tix	Expand

1 - 3	Oops All Lands	suvelaspurgy	$ 528	2 tix	Expand

1 - 4	Azorius Allies	trapzomba	$ 55	1 tix	Expand

-	Excruciator Combo	mtglew	$ 460	2 tix	Expand

-	Mono Blue Tempo	richley	$ 42	1 tix	Expand

-	Excruciator Combo	planaroverload	$ 452	2 tix	Expand

Displaying 1 - 43 of 43 in total.

New Cards Being Played

Card	Decks
Spell Pierce #63 (12)	Simic Nadu (9 - 0) , Azorius Legends Aggro (7 - 2) , Simic Nadu (6 - 2) , Simic Nadu (6 - 2) , Simic Nadu (5 - 2) , ...
Yavimaya Coast #425 (8)	Simic Nadu (9 - 0) , Simic Nadu (6 - 2) , Simic Nadu (6 - 2) , Simic Nadu (5 - 2) , Simic Nadu (4 - 2) , ...
Flooded Grove #364 (7)	Simic Nadu (9 - 0) , Simic Nadu (6 - 2) , Simic Nadu (6 - 2) , Simic Nadu (5 - 2) , Simic Nadu (4 - 2) , ...
Remorseful Cleric #31 (7)	Boros Legends Aggro (5 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (4 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (3 - 3) , Boros Legends Aggro (3 - 3) , Boros Legends Aggro (2 - 4) , ...
Rugged Prairie #174 (7)	Boros Legends Aggro (5 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (4 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (3 - 3) , Boros Legends Aggro (3 - 3) , Boros Legends Aggro (2 - 4) , ...
Battlefield Forge #58 (7)	Boros Legends Aggro (5 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (4 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (3 - 3) , Boros Legends Aggro (3 - 3) , Boros Legends Aggro (2 - 4) , ...
Hinterland Harbor #371 (5)	Simic Nadu (9 - 0) , Simic Nadu (6 - 2) , Simic Nadu (6 - 2) , Simic Nadu (5 - 2) , Unctus (4 - 2)
Burst Lightning #109 (5)	Red Deck Wins (4 - 3) , Boros Legends Aggro (5 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (4 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (2 - 4) , Red Deck Wins (2 - 3)
Clifftop Retreat #155 (4)	Boros Legends Aggro (5 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (4 - 2) , Boros Legends Aggro (2 - 4) , Boros Legends Aggro (1 - 3)
Furycalm Snarl #397 (3)	Boros Legends Aggro (3 - 3) , Boros Legends Aggro (3 - 3) , Boros Legends Aggro (1 - 3)
Isolated Chapel #373 (2)	Necrotic Ooze Combo (5 - 2) , Stax (3 - 3)
Fetid Heath #391 (2)	Necrotic Ooze Combo (5 - 2) , Stax (3 - 3)
Dig Through Time #263 (2)	Mono Blue Tempo (4 - 2) , Dimir Control (3 - 3)
Temple of Malady #700 (2)	Oops All Lands (4 - 2) , Oops All Lands (1 - 2)
Temple of Mystery #311 (2)	Oops All Lands (4 - 2) , Oops All Lands (1 - 2)
Disdainful Stroke #39 (2)	Dimir Control (3 - 3) , Mono Blue Tempo (-)
Laelia, the Blade Reforged #246 (1)	Laelia Cascade (2 - 3)
Shivan Reef #404 (1)	Laelia Cascade (2 - 3)
Return to the Ranks #76 Borderless Full-Art Japanese Showcase (1)	Azorius Allies (1 - 4)
Cascade Bluffs #153 (1)	Laelia Cascade (2 - 3)
Ophiomancer #118 (1)	Stax (3 - 3)
Angel's Grace #67 Borderless Japanese Showcase (1)	Mono White Angels (3 - 3)
Solemn Simulacrum #277 (1)	Mono Black Midrange (3 - 3)
Ozolith, the Shattered Spire #281 (1)	Hardened Scales Affinity (4 - 2)
Hardened Scales #272 (1)	Hardened Scales Affinity (4 - 2)
Temple of Epiphany #699 (1)	Oops All Lands (4 - 2)
Vineglimmer Snarl #323 (1)	Unctus (4 - 2)
Quandrix Command #280 (1)	Simic Nadu (5 - 2)
Caves of Koilos #283 (1)	Necrotic Ooze Combo (5 - 2)
Animate Dead #207 (1)	Necrotic Ooze Combo (5 - 2)

Metagame Summary

Deck	Percentage	Total
Excruciator Combo	18.60%	8
Boros Legends Aggro	16.28%	7
Simic Nadu	13.95%	6
Other	13.95%	6
Red Deck Wins	4.65%	2
Mono Blue Tempo	4.65%	2
Bard Class	2.33%	1
Mono White Humans	2.33%	1
Lifegain Midrange	2.33%	1
Laelia Cascade	2.33%	1
Primal Prayers Combo	2.33%	1
Stax	2.33%	1
Azorius Control	2.33%	1
Hive Mind	2.33%	1
Orzhov Angels	2.33%	1
Mono Black Midrange	2.33%	1
Hardened Scales Affinity	2.33%	1
Necrotic Ooze Combo	2.33%	1
Total	100.00%	43

Most-Played Cards

Top Cards
	Card	Copies	Decks
1	Dark Ritual #82	54	33%
2	Duress #98	44	28%
3	Spell Pierce #63	38	28%
4	Thalia, Guardian of Thraben #318 Showcase	37	23%
5	Defense Grid #13 Retro	37	23%
6	Doomsday Excruciator #94	36	21%
7	Altar of Dementia #218	36	21%
8	Lost Legacy #88	36	26%
9	Mana Leak #62	36	21%
10	Chain Lightning #316 Retro	34	21%

Top Creatures
	Card	Copies	Decks
1	Thalia, Guardian of Thraben #318 Showcase	37	23%
2	Doomsday Excruciator #94	36	21%
3	Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel #293 Showcase Foil	33	23%
4	Horror of the Broken Lands #95	32	19%
5	Imposing Vantasaur #17	32	19%
6	Kytheon, Hero of Akros #23	32	19%
7	Lurching Rotbeast #69	32	19%
8	Archfiend of Ifnir #70	28	19%
9	Senu, Keen-Eyed Protector #181 Foil Etched	26	16%
10	Merry, Esquire of Rohan #215	24	14%

Top Spells
	Card	Copies	Decks
1	Dark Ritual #82	54	33%
2	Duress #98	44	28%
3	Spell Pierce #63	38	28%
4	Defense Grid #13 Retro	37	23%
5	Altar of Dementia #218	36	21%
6	Lost Legacy #88	36	26%
7	Mana Leak #62	36	21%
8	Chain Lightning #316 Retro	34	21%
9	Living Death #185	32	19%
10	Price of Progress #1026	31	21%